Athey Family Genealogy Forum
I think this is mixed up. My sources show that the Elizabeth Fenley (born 26 May 1720) who married Thomas Athey (born c 1695) was the daughter, NOT the sister, of Charles Fenley (who married Elizabeth Harris).
Charles Fenley may indeed have had a sister named Elizabeth, but I believe it was his daughter Elizabeth who married Thomas Athey. (BTW, Charles Fenley and Elizabeth Harris were married 11 Apr 1711 in Prince Georges, MD and had 10 children of which I am aware [per "Colonial Settlers of Prince George's County, Maryland", page 9, ref. King George's Parish Records, pp. 283, 290]).
Notify Administrator about this message?