Re: Mackinlay Surname DNA Project
-
In reply to:
Mackinlay Surname DNA Project
Robert McKinlay 1/27/04
Dear Larry,
In composing a recent letter, I realized that at the time I created Clann Mackinlay Seannachaidh , I started the message boards with the idea that folks could use them as networking tools among themselves & I hadn't planned on interacting with the messages themselves.As the website grew, so did the list of message boards.It would be a logistical nightmare to check 10 sites repeatedly.Hence, I did not realize that you had replied to my initial message, which was really designed to be an announcement, rather than an invitation to discuss it - until I was apprised of your message recently.
To answer your question, most authorities believe that less than 37 marker Y-DNA testing is too insensitive to provide meaningful data on MRCA & close matches.I would recommend no less than a 25 marker test to begin with, but for the serious individual, I'd cut to the chase & go with 37 markers.I've personally upgraded to the 67 marker level of sensitivity.All it takes is a phone call to Houston & either a credit card or they'll invoice you.No further swabbing is necesary.It's smart to join a Surname Project as there is a discount that then applies.
It's tough to fudge DNA results.
If you'd like to communicate with me individually, may I suggest you send an e-mail to [email protected]
Regards aye,
Bob