I descend from another branch of this family, namely that of Nathaniel's sister Elizabeth Payson b.April 23, 1753 in Dorchester, MA (Dorchester VRs, p. 150). I have found documentation for the births of only four of the likely 13 children born to Jonathan Payson and his wife Elizabeth Tileston: Elizabeth, Ann, and Jonathan, all in the Dorchester VRs. Also Mary in the Boston VRs. Do you have documentation for Nathaniel? Would you be willing to share it? Was he born in Annapolis, NS? Where did he die? Thanks for any help you can offer!
By the way, "my" Elizabeth Payson m. Benjamin Snow of Plymouth, New Hampshire in Nova Scotia and returned with him to NH about 1787.