Your list of Thomas Pettygrove's children is all the same Thomas, but on your list are only four of his eleven children. There was a John Pettygrove, son of Thomas baptised 19 Nov 1808. I believe that Elizabeth was baptised immediately because I don't think she lived very long, although I don't have a death date for her. Thomas and Mary McCurdy had John, Thomas, Neal McCurdy, Caroline Elizabeth, Elizabeth, Sarah Ann (my gr gr grandmother), Mary Charlotte, Francis William, William A, Abigail R, and Lucy V.
If you'd like to share information please email me directly at email@example.com
If you are in that area, maybe you can help me solve a puzzle.