Could this be your George SHONER in 1880? FamilySearch database of the 1880 Census, Waterloo, DeKalb, IN (just across the state line, about fifty miles west of Archbold, OH): George SHONER, 41, tanner, Württemberg. Würt. Würt.; wf. Mary, 37, NY NY NY; dau. Mary, 18, b. MI; dau. Lilly, 14, b. OH; three ch. b. IN: Charles, 11; Emma, 11; & Della, 7.
What was the name of the sister that m. August FRAAS? What connections make you think that Frederick was George's brother?