Theron and others researching Sarah Eletha, after Tibbets died, she married a John or Benjamin (I have been given both names) Hobaugh. With him, she had several more children, one of whom was my great grandmother, Amanda Melvina Hobaugh. There was a Joseph, Sarah, and others. Hobaugh went back to Germany, and never returned. She was married to a Raynor at time of her death, or at least death certificate has that name, but her Tibbets children, James, George, etc., buried her under name of Tibbets, per her headstone.